INSANITY IN CANADA: Depression and Eating Disorders Now Floated as Reasons for Assisted Death
A psychiatrist tells MPs that mental illness could qualify for euthanasia — as critics warn Canada is crossing a dangerous moral line.
One-time or recurring donations can be made through Ko-Fi:
⚡ What aren’t they telling you? Please Join Exposing the Darkness News on Telegram.
Canada’s euthanasia debate took a disturbing turn when a psychiatrist told Members of Parliament that individuals suffering from depression or eating disorders could, under certain circumstances, qualify for Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD).
As the country considers expanding assisted suicide to include mental illness, critics warn Canada may be moving away from treatment and toward offering death as a solution to suffering.
For many observers, the discussion raises troubling historical parallels.
Commentators, physicians, and ethicists have increasingly warned that expanding euthanasia for non-terminal conditions echoes the logic seen during early 20th-century eugenics movements, including policies in Nazi Germany, where vulnerable individuals with mental illness or disabilities were deemed lives “not worth living.”
Lifenews reports:
During a Special Joint Committee meeting related to Canada’s euthanasia laws, a psychiatrist told MPs that those with eating disorders or depression should be allowed to die by assisted suicide.
Last week, Dr. Mona Gupta, who works as a psychiatrist and professor at the University of Montreal, was asked directly by pro-life Conservative MP Andrew Lawton if those with depression or eating disorders should be allowed to die by “MAiD” (Medical Assistance in Dying).
Gupta seemed to suggest that this could be OK.
“It depends on the circumstances of the person,” she responded to Lawton.
In reply, Lawton asked, “So it could?”
“Potentially,” Gupta replied.
Lawton then asked Gupta if there is a consensus on how many times a person would have to be treated for disorders before it became enough for them to be considered “treatment resistant.”
In reply, Gupta said that the term “treatment resistant” is not used in MAiD laws.
Last month, the Canadian government created the Special Joint Parliamentary Committee for MAiD. It is filled with euthanasia advocates, but Lawton is one of the few pro-life members of the committee.
The committee will determine whether or not Canada should expand assisted suicide to those with mental illness, but a few Members of Parliament on the committee promise to advocate for life.
Canada’s current MAiD laws state that a person who has a grievous and irremediable sickness must have “enduring and intolerable physical or psychological suffering that cannot be alleviated under conditions the person considers acceptable” before being allowed to request it.
Lawton questioned Gupta as to whether it was reasonable for a person to have to go through all treatments before MAiD would be considered.
“It is difficult to make rules for diagnosis – we have to look at the individual person,” she said.
“Ordinary clinical practice would be pursuing all of the usual standard accepted treatments for conditions – and then some,” added Gupta, noting, “but there may be reasons an individual has that they can’t take advantage of those treatments.”
Lawton asked Gupta if sick people who did not want treatment could just then go ahead with MAiD.
In reply, Gupta said if a patient did not want treatment, it would then not be “appropriate to consider MAiD in that circumstance.”
Instances of Canadians being pressured into MAiD over medical treatment have been on the rise in recent months.
As reported by LifeSiteNews, an 84-year-old Canadian Catholic woman who was offered euthanasia while at a hospital despite not being deathly sick has spoken out, saying there was “no way” she was going to “take measures to end” her life.
Indeed, as reported by LifeSiteNews, a Canadian man was euthanized just because he had partial blindness.
Some provinces such as Alberta are doing what they can to limit the availability of MAiD, which is federally mandated.
As reported by LifeSiteNews, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith’s United Conservative Party (UCP) government was the first in Canada to introduce a bill that would severely limit who can get euthanasia and ban it for minors. The UCP said that the bill is to “strengthen protections for vulnerable Albertans” as well as allow doctors and hospitals to refuse to offer assisted suicide.
In February 2024, the federal government delayed the mental illness expansion until 2027 after pushback from pro-life, medical, and mental health groups as well as most of Canada’s provinces.
The Liberal government under Trudeau and current Prime Minister Mark Carney, however, has worked to expand euthanasia 13-fold since it was legalized in 2016. Canada now has the fastest-growing assisted-suicide program in the world. Meanwhile, Health Canada released a series of studies on advanced requests for assisted suicide.
Euthanasia is now the sixth-leading cause of death in Canada after it was not listed in Statistics Canada’s top 10 leading causes of death from 2019 to 2022.
Related articles:
But not transgender?
This demon doctor speaks for many fellow who won't fess up to the fact their treatments are responsible not just for mass failure but also mass worsening of the mental health of many that go to them for care....that is if you can actually find a medical doctor with relevant experience to treat your condition in Canada.